The New York Times is reporting
that New York City Mayor-elect Bill de Blasio has chosen William
Bratton to succeed Ray Kelly as commissioner of the New York Police
Department. This will be Bratton’s second stint in charge of the NYPD;
he also ran the department during the Giuliani administration, and
received much credit for the substantial drop in the city’s crime rate
during his tenure. Since then, Bratton has gone on to command the Los
Angeles Police Department, work in private industry, serve as a criminal
justice commentator on NBC, and, weirdly, be named a Commander of the Most Excellent Order of the British Empire. (Bratton narrowly beat out de Blasio’s second choice for the job: Sir Archibald Whitworth of Sussex.)
Bratton will be expected to keep the city safe while simultaneously
renewing New Yorkers’ confidence in a police department that has been
sharply criticized in recent years, most often for its divisive stop-and-frisk policy.
(De Blasio has promised to reform stop-and-frisk, and this will be one
of Bratton’s most important jobs.) There are plenty of reasons to think
that Bratton’s up to the task. He has a reputation as a brilliant
tactician and a lifelong innovator, a leader who’s good with
organizational management and unafraid to delegate authority. He’s also
an ambitious self-promoter who thinks very well of himself. That doesn’t
really bother me: If hustlers and narcissists were disqualified from
holding public office, then every city hall in America would be empty.
But there are a couple of other, more substantial reasons why I think
it’s valid to question whether Bratton is really the best man for the
job.
Read on...
Read on...